Title: Origin of the bright prompt optical emission in the naked eye burst
ArXiv ID: 1101.3952
Date: 2015-05-27
Authors: R. Hasco’et (1 and 2), F. Daigne (1 and 2), R. Mochkovitch (1 and 2) ((1) UPMC Univ Paris 06, UMR 7095, Institut dAstrophysique de Paris (2) CNRS, UMR 7095, Institut dAstrophysique de Paris)
📝 Abstract
The huge optical brightness of GRB 080319B (the "Naked Eye Burst) makes this event really challenging for models of the prompt GRB emission. In the framework of the internal shock model, we investigate a scenario where the dominant radiative process is synchrotron emission and the high optical flux is due to the dynamical properties of the relativistic outflow: if the initial Lorentz factor distribution in the jet is highly variable, many internal shocks will form within the outflow at various radii. The most violent shocks will produce the main gamma-ray component while the less violent ones will contribute at lower energy, including the optical range.
💡 Deep Analysis
📄 Full Content
arXiv:1101.3952v1 [astro-ph.HE] 20 Jan 2011
Origin of the bright prompt optical emission in
the naked eye burst
R. Hascoët∗,†, F. Daigne1∗,† and R. Mochkovitch∗,†
∗UPMC Univ Paris 06, UMR 7095, Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris, F-75014, Paris, France
†CNRS, UMR 7095, Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris, F-75014, Paris, France
Abstract. The huge optical brightness of GRB 080319B (the ”Naked Eye Burst”) makes this event
really challenging for models of the prompt GRB emission. In the framework of the internal shock
model, we investigate a scenario where the dominant radiative process is synchrotron emission and
the high optical flux is due to the dynamical properties of the relativistic outflow: if the initial
Lorentz factor distribution in the jet is highly variable, many internal shocks will form within the
outflow at various radii. The most violent shocks will produce the main gamma-ray component
while the less violent ones will contribute at lower energy, including the optical range.
Keywords: γ-ray sources; γ-ray bursts
PACS: 98.70.Rz
INTRODUCTION
Due to a fortunate chain of events, GRB 080319B was observed in the γ-ray and the
optical domains with a high temporal resolution, during the whole prompt emission
[1]. It peaked at a visual magnitude V=5.3, making in principle this event visible with
the naked-eye, despite its cosmological distance (z=0.937). To explain this huge opti-
cal brightness, different scenarios have already been proposed. The broadband spectrum
could be produced by the Synchro-Self Compton (SSC) mechanism [1, 2, 3], or by the
Synchrotron emission from two distinct electron populations in the same emitting re-
gion [4]. We have investigated these two possibilities in the framework of the internal
shock model, using a detailed radiative code for the emission from shock accelerated
electrons [5]. Both scenarios face severe difficulties (energy crisis, self-absorption fre-
quency above the optical), as also suggested by other studies [4]. We present in these
proceedings a new scenario where the optical brightness is produced by the synchrotron
emission of a highly variable relativistic outflow, as also suggested by [6].
BRIGHT OPTICAL EMISSION FROM A HIGHLY VARIABLE
RELATIVISTIC OUTFLOW
Using a simplified approach of the dynamics of internal shocks [7] and the standard
prescription for the synchrotron radiation [8], we simulate synthetic GRBs produced
by highly variable jets. Fig.1 presents an example whose properties are very similar
to those of GRB 080319B. During the relativistic ejection by the central engine, the
isotropic equivalent kinetic energy injection rate is assumed to be constant ( ˙Ekin =
2·1054 erg·s−1), and the Lorentz factor Γ varies on a timescale of 0.5 s. In this example,
1 Institut Universitaire de France
FIGURE 1.
An example of a synthetic GRB with a bright optical flux. Panel (a): initial distribution
of the Lorentz factor in the outflow. Panel (b): observed peak energy of the spectrum radiated by each
collision, as a function of radius. Bigger dots indicate that the self-absorption frequency is above 2 eV.
Panel (c): light curves in γ-rays (top) and optical (bottom). Panel (d): simulated time-integrated spectrum
(thick line), observed spectrum (thin line), observed optical level (big dot).
for an illustrative purpose, it is forced to be either 200 or 800 with equal probability
(Fig.1a). The total ejection lasts for 25 s which leads to an observed burst duration of
the order of 50 s at z ∼1. Two series of internal shocks occur, which contribute either
in soft γ-rays or at lower energy, depending on the violence of the collision (Fig.1b).
For collisions at small radii, synchrotron self-absorption suppresses the contribution in
the optical range. The predicted lightcurves show several features observed in GRB
080319B: compared to γ-rays, the optical lightcurve is less variable, and starts and
ends with a delay (Fig.1c). The spectrum clearly shows the two different components
associated to the two series of shocks (Fig.1d). However the low-energy slope α in the
γ-ray range does not reproduce the observed value. This is a well known problem, which
is not specific to the naked eye burst. It probably indicates that the expected prediction of
the fast cooling synchrotron spectrum α = −1.5 [8] is too simple. Several effects, such
as inverse Compton scatterings in Klein-Nishina regime [9], can steepen the spectrum.
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
To test the robustness of the proposed scenario, we performed a set of simulations,
where several hundreds of synthetic bursts were generated with different realizations
of the initial distribution of the Lorentz factor, assuming that it varies on a timescale
of 0.5 s taking random values uniformly distributed between 200 and 800. The kinetic
energy flux is adjusted in each case to keep the radiated energy in γ-rays constant (and
similar to the observed value in GRB 080319B). This Monte Carlo analysis shows that
a highly variable outflow has a fa